addarrow-downarrow-outlinearrow-outline-downarrow-outline-leftarrow-outline-uparrow-upclosedownloadformat-pdfhelpinfoinfo-outlinelink-external-outlinemenusearchsource-handshakesource-klsource-web

Bidding

The central step of procuring PPP projects is the management of the bid process. The bid process ends with the selection of a preferred bidder, with whom the implementing agency then works to execute the contract and reach financial close.

The primary steps are:

  1. Preparing and issuing request for proposal (RFP) documents
  2. Interacting with bidders during proposal preparation
  3. Receiving bids
  4. Evaluating bids
  5. Finalizing the contract with the selected bidder

Preparing and issuing request for proposal documents

The bid process begins when the government issues RFP documents to participating bidders. These documents set out the project structure and requirements, and the details of the bid process. High-quality, detailed, and clear RFP documents are important to ensuring a competitive process and a PPP that responds to the government’s objectives.

RFP documents typically include the following information on the PPP opportunity:

  • An information memorandum describing the key features of the project and the commercial terms of the PPP
  • Draft project contract
  • Copies of any permits or approvals
  • A description of the detailed technical information amassed during the project preparation stage provided to bidders in a data room
  • Information on the bid process:
  • Detailed bid rules and instructions, including a timetable and how and to what extend bidders can interact with government
  • Evaluation criteria
  • Bid bond requirements (if any)

Interacting with bidders during proposal preparation

After the RFP documents have been issued, bidders will prepare detailed proposals responding to the requirements of the RFP. During this preparation process the RFP usually allows for controlled interaction between the bidders and government. At a minimum, this interaction involves providing information to bidders, and responding to requests for clarification on the RFP. In some cases, the government may consider updating the RFP documents as a result. Channels for these types of communication include:

  • Data room:  physical or virtual, where bidders can find all available information relevant to the project.
  • Question and answer iterations: where bidders submit questions in writing and the implementing agency responds in writing to all bidders (ensuring that all bidders have access to the same information).
  • Bidders’ conferences: where the implementing agency presents the project and respond to questions from bidders.

Some governments use an interactive tender or competitive dialogue process, which involves more extensive engagement with bidders as they prepare their proposals. Under this type of process, bidders submit technical proposals, which are then the subject of feedback and discussion with the contracting authority, to refine the proposed solutions to meet the authority’s needs, before submitting a final proposal.

Receiving bids

A reliable and credible system to ensure bids are handled confidentially is important. This prevents any opportunity for bid tampering, and protects commercially sensitive information in bids.

Often bids are delivered in hard copy in sealed envelopes. Typically financial and technical bids are delivered in separate envelopes—financial bids are only opened for bidders that pass the technical assessment, and are often opened publicly to avoid any possibility of bid tampering—although an electronic system can be considered as an alternative. One advantage of an electronic system is that it prevents bidders from monitoring or interfering with physical bid delivery.

Evaluating bids

The evaluation process involves:

  • Assessing bid completeness, and compliance with minimum requirements of bid process
  • Bid clarification, which can involve a bidder presentation and a Q&A session
  • Detailed review by evaluation teams, following the pre-defined evaluation criteria
  • Preparation of evaluation reports, detailing the process followed and the analysis of the evaluation teams

Evaluation criteria should be decided in advance, and set out in the RFP documentation. Evaluation criteria typically incorporate technical and financial elements. These may be evaluated separately—typically with a pass/fail technical evaluation, followed by ranking on financial criteria or combined and weighted to rank bids. Where technical requirements have been clearly set out in the proposal, technical evaluation requires checking compliance with those requirements.

Many PPPs are ranked on the basis of a financial criterion, subject to passing other technical and financial requirements. The most common option for a financial evaluation criterion is the remuneration of the private sector. This could be the lowest tariff to users, or lowest cost to government (whether as a government-pays PPP, or as a subsidy in addition to user charges). Related criteria can include length of concession, or amount of investment.

Finalizing the PPP contract with the selected bidder

Once the preferred bidder has been selected, governments sometimes enter into further discussion with the bidder to finalize the PPP contract. While extensive negotiation at this stage can undermine the competitive tender process, some level of negotiation may be necessary to clarify elements of the proposal or contract, particularly when the bid process has not included significant interaction. If financing arrangements have not already been finalized, lenders may also have demands at this stage that create pressure to negotiate on elements of the contract and risk allocation. Governments should define and limit the extent of negotiations possible at this stage.

Failed Bids

If only one bid is received, this can raise concerns about whether that bid will provide value for money. There are two broad options in this case, depending on the reason for only receiving one bid:

  • Re-package and re-tender: this may be the best approach if the low turnout seems to be because of deficiency in the tender
  • Conduct thorough due diligence and select the sole bidder: may be a better option if it appears that the bidder believed the process would be competitive, and is in full compliance with the requirements

In some cases, despite multiple bids being received, there may not be a clear preferred bidder. This could be because no bids conform to requirements or because a non-conforming bid appears to present a better value-for-money option than conforming bids. 

One option if no bids conform, and none appear to be of high quality, is simply to re-package and re-tender the project. The alternative is to extend the procurement process, to identify a preferred bidder: typically through discussions with the higher-ranked bidders on the points where the bids do not conform, often followed by asking for a revised bid.

Learn More

    • 2014
    • Asian Development Bank (ADB), World Bank Group (WBG), Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), PPIAF

    Bidding

    PPP Reference Guide Version 2.0

    Section 3.5.4 of the PPP Reference Guide deals with managing the bidding process.  This may follow prequalification and ends with the selection of a preferred bidder, with whom the implementing then works to execute the contract and reach financial close. This section describes and provides guidance on the following elements of managing the bid process: • Preparing and issuing Request for Proposal (RFP) documents • Interacting with bidders during the bidding period • Receiving bids • Evaluating bids to select the preferred bidder • Dealing with problems such as receiving only one bid, or no fully compliant bids • Finalizing the contract with the preferred bidder. The PPP Reference Guide presents a global overview of the diversity of...

    • 2010
    • Edward Farquharson, Clemencia Torres de Mästle, E.R. Yescombe, and Javier Encinas
    • PPIAF

    How to Engage with the Private Sector in Public-Private Partnerships in Emerging Markets

    This guide reviews the necessary steps to successfully engage and manage a public-private partnership (PPP) from the early stages. It presents a framework that highlights the requirements, options, and challenges that governments face when embarking into PPPs, and explains how to address them so that a sound PPP program can be implemented and the benefits for both public and private partners can fully materialize. This book draws on experiences from both mature and developing PPP markets across the world, and case studies illustrate the key messages throughout. It discusses the policies, processes, and institutions needed to select the right projects and then manage preparation for market and operation. It identifies the underlying...

    • 2004
    • Jose Luis Guasch
    • World Bank Group (WBG)

    Granting and Renegotiating Infrastructure Concessions: Doing it Right

    The book breaks new ground in relation to the design and implementation of concession contracts by culling the lessons of experience from some 1,000 examples and assessing what these lessons mean for future practice. The examples are taken from Latin America where, during the 1990s, governments throughout the region awarded contracts to the private sector to operate a range of public utilities, including electricity; water supply and sanitation; and airport, railway, and port services. The study shows the extent to which the concession award process, the contract design, the regulatory framework, and the overall governance structure tend to drive the success of any reform effort and the likelihood of contract renegotiation.

    • 2011
    • World Bank Group (WBG)

    Guidelines: Procurement of Goods, Works, and Non-Consulting Services under IBRD Loans and IDA Credits and Grants

    • 2006
    • World Bank Group (WBG)

    Sample Bidding Document: Procurement of Works and Services under Output- and Performance-based Road Contracts

    This Sample Bidding Document for Procurement of Works and Services under Output-and Performance-Based Road Contracts (OPRC) has been issued by the World Bank on a trial basis to provide its clients with an alternative to the traditional methods of procuring road reconstruction, rehabilitation and maintenance. The documents are a further development of the earlier “Sample Bidding Documents for Procurement of Performance-based Management and Maintenance of Roads (PMMR)” which were issued by the Bank in February 2002. As their predecessor, these documents are focused to fit the specific nature of Performance-based Management and Maintenance of Roads (PMMR), but they are also suitable for the procurement of works and services under...

    • 2014
    • European Investment Bank (EIB)

    The EPEC PPP Guide

    The European PPP Expertise Centre (EPEC) has published several versions of its Guide to Guidance over the last few years. The Guide to Guidance is principally aimed at public procuring authorities considering the use of public-private partnership (PPP) arrangements. Given the positive feedback it has received, EPEC decided to turn the Guide to Guidance into a webtool rebranded as the EPEC PPP Guide. The aim of the EPEC PPP Guide is to give users easy access to regularly updated PPP guidance and allow them to interact with the EPEC team (e.g. propose new guidance, rate the EPEC PPP Guide).  

    • 2008
    • Asian Development Bank (ADB)

    Public-Private Partnership Handbook

    This Public–Private Partnership (PPP) Handbook is designed for the staff of the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and its developing member countries’ clients. It provides an overview of the role, design, structure, and execution of PPPs for infrastructure development. With inputs from policy and transaction specialists, this handbook addresses a range of matters associated with PPPs, from policy considerations to implementation issues. Each of the 10 chapters focuses on a specific area of information about PPPs:

    • Chapter 1: introduces and defines PPPs and their context within infrastructure and development finance.
    • Chapter 2: gives examples of evolving PPP experience within various infrastructure sectors.
    • Chapter 3: describes...

    • 2015
    • Government of Australia

    National Public Private Partnership Guidelines - Volume 2: Practitioners’ Guide, Australia

    The Practitioners’ Guide is one of the detailed guidance documents that form part of the Guidelines. It provides guidance to government departments and agencies across jurisdictions on how PPP processes should be implemented in a consistent manner. The Practitioners’ Guide is specifically drafted to apply to the implementation of a project from the point of a government decision to proceed with a project as a PPP. It does not attempt to address issues related to the process for government approval of the project or the process for assessing different procurement options. Once government has approved the project to proceed as a PPP, the Procuring Agency must deliver the project consistent with these Guidelines. However, given these...

    • Government of Australia

    National PPP Guidelines: Practitioners’ Guide, Australia

    The website portal for PPPs in Austrailia.

    • 2009
    • PPIAF
    • PPIAF

    Toolkit for Public-Private Partnerships in Roads and Highways

    The Toolkit is a reference guide for public authorities in developing countries for the development of PPP (public-private partnership) programs in the highways sector, particularly in assisting in PPP policy development, project preparation and the sourcing and monitoring of external expertise. It provides guidance in the definition of strategy and policy for PPP, the characteristics of PPP projects and the stages for their preparation. Module 4, "Laws & Contracts" https://ppiaf.org/sites/ppiaf.org/files/documents/toolkits/highwaystoolkit/4/index.html examines the legal framework and regulatory environment for PPPs.  It provides a framework for diagnosis and reform and provides the basis for preparation of PPP contracts. Module 5,...

    • 2006
    • PPIAF

    Approaches to Private Participation in Water Services: A Toolkit

    This Toolkit assists developing country governments that are interested in using private firms to help expand access to safe water and sanitation services at reasonable cost. It also aims to assist in the design of arrangements that maximize the benefits for their countries, provinces, or municipalities.

    • 2012
    • Government of Singapore

    Public Private Partnership Handbook

    This document published by Singapore's Ministry of Finance provides an introduction to the concept of Public Private Partnership (PPP) covering PPP delivery models and the roles of the public and private sectors in PPP Projects. It also explores the structuring process, procurement process, and management of a PPP relationship in depth.

    • 2004
    • Government of South Africa
    • Government of South Africa

    Public-Private Partnership Manual, South Africa

    Main Introduction and Table of Contents

    South Africa is amongst the leading countries in the world in the law, policy and systems it has established for public private partnerships. The South African National Treasury’s PPP Manual is a best practice guide for PPP practitioners. Each module of the PPP Manual is issued as a National Treasury PPP Practice Note in terms of the Public Finance Management Act, 1999 (PFMA). It should be read with Standardised PPP Provisions, issued as National Treasury PPP Practice Note Number 01 of 2004.  

    • 2010
    • HM Treasury, United Kingdom

    HM Treasury Review of Competitive Dialogue

    Competitive dialogue is a public-sector tendering option that allows for bidders to develop alternative proposals in response to a client’s outline requirements. Only when their proposals are developed to sufficient detail are tenderers invited to submit competitive bids. The aims are to increase value by encouraging innovation and to maintain competitive pressure in bidding for complex contracts. This review has considered the impact of the competitive dialogue process on public sector procurements in the UK. Following a series of questionnaires and roundtable discussions with public and private sector participants in procurements which have used competitive dialogue, this review provides recommendations to improve the procurement...

    • 1993
    • Government of Colombia

    Ley 80 de 1993 (Colombia)

    Reglamentada por el Decreto Nacional 734 de 2012, Modificada  por la Ley 1150 de 2007, Reglamentada parcialmente por los Decretos Nacionales 679 de 1994, 626 de 2001, 2170 de 2002, 3629 y 3740 de 2004, 959, 2434 y 4375 de 2006; 2474 de 2008 y 2473 de 2010 Por la cual se expide el Estatuto General de Contratación de la Administración Pública

    • 1993
    • Government of Philippines

    Republic Act No. 7718, Philippines

    The Philippine BOT Law and its Implementing Rules & Regulations

    An act amending certain sections of republic act no. 6957, entitled “An act authorizing the financing, construction, operation and maintenance of infrastructure projects by the private sector, and for other purposes.”

    • 2014
    • Asian Development Bank (ADB), World Bank Group (WBG), Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), PPIAF

    Licitacion

    Asociaciones Publico-Privadas: Guia de Referencia Version 2.0

For legal and regulatory resources go to PPPIRC

Explore PPP Cycle